All vulnerabilities

Servers and applications

GHSA-pr4w-cfq5-99h2

Authenticated user can restore another user's backup archive into their own account (missing backup-ownership check in the restore flow)

Severity
Medium
Published
24 Aug 2026
Last changed
24 Aug 2026
Added to UpHeron
3 Nov 2026
Fixed in
1.9.10
Weakness
Authorization bypass through a user-controlled key (IDOR) (CWE-639)Missing authorization (CWE-862)
Sources
Project advisories (GitHub)

Description

Hi HestiaCP team,

Please find below a security report for an authorization issue in the backup-restore flow. I've kept it to the required format (description, services involved, tested version, reproduction steps, findings, and expected results).

An authenticated panel user (role user is sufficient) can schedule and execute a restore of another user's backup archive into their own account, because the restore flow never verifies that the archive belongs to the acting user. The sibling delete flow performs this exact check, and the asymmetry is directly reproducible.

  • CWE-639 — Authorization Bypass Through User-Controlled Key
  • CWE-862 — Missing Authorization

The ownership boundary for a backup archive is the per-user registry $HESTIA/data/users//backup.conf, enforced via is_object_valid 'backup' 'BACKUP' "$backup", which resolves to a grep over that file:

The delete flow enforces it:

From hestiacp/hestiacp's security advisory. Shortened; the full text is there.

Workarounds

  • Restrict backup-archive filenames from user-reachable surfaces until patched.
  • Ensure the shared backup directory is not readable/guessable across users, and audit any channel that could leak a victim's backup timestamp (notifications, logs).
  • As a partial mitigation, administrators can disable per-user backups (BACKUP_SYSTEM) for untrusted tenants.

Reported by Ahmed Ibrahim (@skeletonsec). Independently validated in a local test environment.

Workarounds as given by hestiacp/hestiacp's security advisory.

Affected software

SoftwareAffected versions
Hestia Control PanelServers and applications · github:hestiacp/hestiacp
  • Every version before 1.9.10

About Hestia Control Panel

Hestia Control Panel | A lightweight and powerful control panel for the modern web.

From its GitHub repository.
GitHub stars
4,578GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Forks
964GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Latest release
1.10.7GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Released
13 Nov 2026GitHub
License
GPL-3.0GitHub
First published on GitHub
7 Nov 2018GitHub

References