All vulnerabilities

Servers and applications

GHSA-j344-gqv4-84ff

Cross-Organization Authentication Method Enumeration

Severity
Medium 5.3
Published
4 Sept 2026
Last changed
4 Sept 2026
Added to UpHeron
3 Nov 2026
Fixed in
4.17.3
Weakness
Missing authorization (CWE-862)
Attack
Over the network · Needs a user account · No user action needed
Attacker can
Read some data
CVSS vector
CVSS:4.0/AV:N/AC:L/AT:N/PR:L/UI:N/VC:L/VI:N/VA:N/SC:N/SI:N/SA:N
Sources
Project advisories (GitHub)

Description

ZITADEL’s User Service API allowed an authenticated organization member who holds user.read in one organization to learn which authentication methods are configured for a user in any other organization on the same instance. The check on GET /v2/users/{userId}/authentication_methods (and the equivalent v2beta path) verified user.read against the caller’s organization context rather than against the organization that owns the target user.

An attacker who is an organization member with user.read in a single organization (for example via ORG_OWNER or the read-only ORG_OWNER_VIEWER role) can:

  • Learn which authentication method types another organization’s user has registered — including password, passkey, TOTP, U2F, OTP-SMS, OTP-Email, IDP, and recovery codes
  • Map attack surface across organizations on the same instance (for example, whether a target account has a local password)
From zitadel/zitadel's security advisory. Shortened; the full text is there.

Workarounds

The recommended solution is to upgrade to a patched version. There is no configuration that fully closes this gap on unpatched versions. As a partial mitigation, limit which principals hold org-scoped user.read (including ORG_OWNER_VIEWER and similar custom roles) to trusted operators, and treat unexpected knowledge of other organizations’ user IDs as sensitive.

Workarounds as given by zitadel/zitadel's security advisory.

Affected software

SoftwareAffected versions
ZITADELServers and applications · github:zitadel/zitadel
  • From 3.0.0 up to 3.4.15
  • From 4.0.0 before 4.17.3

About ZITADEL

ZITADEL - Identity infrastructure, simplified for you.

From its GitHub repository.
GitHub stars
15,585GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Forks
1,432GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Latest release
v4.20.3GitHub, 15 Nov 2026
Released
13 Nov 2026GitHub
License
AGPL-3.0GitHub
First published on GitHub
16 Mar 2020GitHub

References